Sunday, March 21, 2010

Burma leader Than Shwe gives election warning


Senior General Than Shwe, archive image
Than Shwe said his roadmap was "the sole process for transition"
Burma's military leader Than Shwe has urged people to make what he called the "correct choices" when elections are held at some point later this year.
General Than Shwe made his comments in a message to mark Independence Day.
He said his government's seven-stage roadmap was the only way for the country to achieve democracy.
A date for the elections has not been set, but they will be the first since 1990, when the military refused to recognise the opposition's victory.
According to the BBC's South East Asia correspondent, Rachel Harvey, the coming year could prove to be a watershed for Burma, but no-one is making any firm predictions on the outcome.
Growing divide
In his annual message read out by another military general at a ceremony in the remote new capital Nay Pyi Taw, Senior General Than Shwe said his seven-step "roadmap to democracy" was "the sole process for transition".
Than Shwe did not spell out exactly what he meant by "correct choices", but many in Burma will interpret his comments as an implicit warning, our correspondent says.
The underlying message appears to be that the military government's plan is the only game in town and it will be played according to the generals' rules.
The election will be the first in Burma since the National League for Democracy (NLD), led by the detained democracy leader Aung San Suu Kyi, won a landslide victory in 1990.
It was a result the military leadership refused to recognise - and the NLD was never allowed to take power.
The NLD has not said whether it intends to contest this year's poll, but in its own Independence Day statement, the party appealed for what it called transparent and sincere dialogue towards national reconciliation.
It also referred to the growing divide between rich and poor in Burma, and said that the majority of people were suffering.
There have been unconfirmed reports in some areas of dissent in the lower ranks of the military over pay and conditions.
Some observers believe that deteriorating economic circumstances as much as political manoeuvring could ultimately decide Burma's future.
The US, which recently changed its policy to one of engagement with the military government, used the occasion of Burma's Independence Day to offer support for the country's independence.
But Washington also said it looked forward to the day when people could freely exercise their universal human rights.

Burma jails journalist Ngwe Soe Lin for 13 years


Map of Burma
A military court in Burma has sentenced a journalist to 13 years in prison for working illegally for foreign media organisations, his lawyer has said.
Ngwe Soe Lin, who reported for the Norway-based Democratic Voice of Burma, was convicted of violating immigration laws and the Electronics Act.
His lawyer, Aung Thein, said there was no proof he had broken any law and would appeal against the conviction.
Most foreign journalists are banned in Burma and the state censors all media.
Ngwe Soe Lin was arrested as he left an internet cafe in the Rangoon area of Kyaukmyaung in June 2009. After being interrogated for two months, he was sent to the city's notorious Insein prison, where his sentence was handed down on Wednesday.
According to the Burma Media Association, which is based in neighbouring Thailand, 14 reporters were arrested in Burma in 2009.
Correspondents say the detentions were part of a continued crackdown by the military authorities on those involved in the mass anti-government protests in September 2007.
In December, freelance journalist Hla Hla Win was jailed for 20 years on similar charges to Ngwe Soe Lin after a military court found she had provided video for the Democratic Voice of Burma.

Burma military passes key election laws


Burma's leader Gen Than Shwe (file image)
Gen Than Shwe has warned people to make "correct choices" in the polls
Burma's military government has approved election laws that pave the way for polls expected this year.
Details of the laws have not yet been revealed but they are likely to include issues such as campaigning and the number of candidates per constituency.
The poll is part of the government's "roadmap to democracy", which has been widely criticised in the West.
Detained pro-democracy leader Aung San Suu Kyi cannot stand and her party has not confirmed it will take part.
It has said it wants to see the details of the new laws before deciding whether to field candidates, and has criticised the timing of the new laws.
The five elections laws will be published in detail on Tuesday, Burma's state media said.
The laws are expected to lay out rules on how long candidates can campaign for, how they will register, how many candidates can run in each constituency and which parties - if any - will have access to state media for their campaign.
The document could also answer the key question of when the elections, the first in 20 years, will be held, says the BBC's South East Asia correspondent Rachel Harvey.
Burma's last general election, in 1990, was overwhelmingly won by Ms Suu Kyi's party, the National League for Democracy (NLD), but the military government annulled the result.
Campaign bar
The authorities have already made it clear that Ms Suu Kyi will not be allowed to take part in the polls.
Aung San Suu Kyi (file image)
Ms Suu Kyi is not expected to be free in time for the elections
She was married to a British academic - and a clause in the constitution bans anyone married to a foreign national from holding political office.
She has been under house arrest for much of the past two decades and in August last year her latest period of detention was extended until November 2010.
The extension was seen by some analysts as a further guarantee for the military that she will not be able to campaign for others in the elections either.
The NLD has not yet said whether it will take part in the elections, as it considers the constitution under which they will be held unfair and aimed at perpetuating military rule.
Spokesman Nyan Win criticised the timing of the new laws so soon before an election is to take place.
"There is not enough time, the parties are not ready, they cannot lobby or campaign," he told reporters on Monday.
General Than Shwe has said his government's seven-stage roadmap is the only way for the country to achieve democracy.
In January, he urged Burmese people to make "correct choices" in the elections.
Correspondents said many people in Burma would interpret the remarks as an implicit warning to back the military.

Burma election laws a 'setback' for dialogue, says US


Burma's generals
The junta's new laws have been widely criticised internationally
The US says Burma's newly-enacted elections laws are a "setback" for political dialogue and the junta's engagement with Washington.
The comments from Assistant Secretary of State Kurt Campbell came as Burma's military rulers unveiled the last of five widely-criticised election laws.
No date has yet been set for the poll, the first in Burma for 20 years.
Meanwhile, a UN special envoy to Burma has accused the country of a "gross and systematic violation of human rights".
In a leaked report, Tomas Ojea Quintana called for an investigation into potential war crimes in Burma.
'Very regrettable'
Burma's military leaders say they plan to hold multi-party elections this year. They have been announcing the laws under which the polls will be held all week.
Many key opposition figures - including detained leader Aung San Suu Kyi - are not allowed to participate.
Members of religious orders are also banned from taking part, a rule which covers the monks who led anti-government protests two years ago.
The possibility exists that some of these human rights violations may entail categories of crimes against humanity or war crimes
Tomas Ojea Quintana, UN envoy
Speaking on a visit to Thailand, Mr Campbell said the US was "very disappointed and ... concerned" by the new laws.
"It's very regrettable. This is not what we had hoped for, and it is a setback," he said.
Last year, the US said it would seek to engage directly with Burma's rulers in a bid to promote democratic ideas, saying sanctions alone would not be effective.
Mr Campbell said the approach had been to "try to encourage domestic dialogue between the key stakeholders" but that the enactment of the new laws "doesn't leave much room for such a dialogue".
He said Washington would continue to talk to leader Gen Than Shwe and the junta, but that sanctions would remain in place.
'Ethnic abuse'
His comments came a day after Mr Quintana's report, which contained severe criticism of the Burmese authorities.
UN Special Envoy Tomas Ojea Quintana in Burma (19 February 2010)
Mr Quintana expressed concern about the treatment of minorities in Burma
Mr Quintana said there was a "pattern of gross and systematic violation of human rights" in the country.
"The possibility exists that some of these human rights violations may entail categories of crimes against humanity or war crimes," he said, in the report to be presented to the UN on Monday.
Mr Quintana, who has visited Burma on three occasions, said "far too many" people in the country were denied access to basic food, shelter, health and education.
He also highlighted concerns about ongoing abuses of civilians in conflict areas around Burma's borders - including the recruitment of child soldiers - and about the treatment of Muslim ethnic groups in the north.

Aung San Suu Kyi: A life in pictures

Aung San Suu Kyi's family in 1947
Aung San Suu Kyi is Burma's opposition heroine, seen here aged two, with her parents and two elder brothers in 1947.

Aung San Suu Kyi sits beneath a portrait of her father General Aung San
As the daughter of General Aung San who led Burma to independence, her homeland was never far from her thoughts.

At her home whilst under house arrest in 1989
After a period of time overseas she returned to Burma in 1988, and was soon put under house arrest at her lakeside residence.

Aung San Suu Kyi making speeches in 1995 after she was released the first time
It was six years before she was released from this first stint in detention.

Burma's pro-democracy leader Aung San Suu Kyi (unseen) and her 12 supporters are locked in cars in a roadside standoff in Dala, a small town just outside Yangon, Sunday, Aug. 27, 2000
But Aung San Suu Kyi continued to suffer restrictions to her movement out of the capital and in 2000 she was again arrested.

Aung San Suu Kyi speaking at a press conference after being freed from 19 months under house arrest,
She was released unconditionally in May 2002, but just over a year later she was put in prison following a clash between her supporters and a government-backed mob. 

Campaigners in the UK protesting for Aung San Suu Kyi to be released.
In September 2003 she was allowed to move back home, but despite intense pressure for her release she has remained under house arres
 
Burmese Prime Minister Soe Win
An apparent power struggle which saw hardliner Soe Win become prime minister in October 2004 further dimmed hopes of Aung San Suu Kyi's quick release.

Ibrahim Gambari touches a statue of Buddha while visiting the historical Shwe Da Gon pagoda in Yangon, 18 May 2006
But hopes were then raised by the junta's agreement to a meeting between senior UN envoy Ibrahim Gambari and Aung San Suu Kyi in May 2006.

Police guard Aung San Suu Kyi as she applauds the demonstrators on 22 September 2007
During anti-government protests led by Buddhist monks in 2007, Ms Suu Kyi made her first public appearance since 2003, greeting monks outside her house and praying with them.

A portrait of detained democracy icon Aung San Suu Kyi is displayed at National League for Democracy (NLD) headquarters in Yangon
For the Burmese people, Aung San Suu Kyi represents their best and perhaps sole hope that one day there will be an end to the country's military repression.



Profile: Aung San Suu Kyi

Like the South African leader Nelson Mandela, Aung San Suu Kyi has become an international symbol of heroic and peaceful resistance in the face of oppression.
Burmese opposition leader Aung San Suu Kyi (13 July 1995)
Aung San Suu Kyi advocates non-violent resistance
For the Burmese people, Ms Suu Kyi, 64, represents their best and perhaps sole hope that one day there will be an end to the country's military repression.
As a pro-democracy campaigner and leader of the opposition National League for Democracy party (NLD), she has spent more than 11 of the past 19 years in some form of detention under Burma's military regime.
In 1991 she was awarded the Nobel Peace Prize for her efforts to bring democracy to Burma.
At the presentation, the Chairman of the Nobel Peace Prize Committee, Francis Sejested, called her "an outstanding example of the power of the powerless".
House arrest
After a period of time overseas, Aung San Suu Kyi went back to Burma in 1988.
Soon after she returned, she was put under house arrest in Rangoon for six years, until she was released in July 1995.
AUNG SAN SUU KYI
1989: Put under house arrest as Burma junta declares martial law
1990: NLD wins election; military disregards result
1991: Wins Nobel Peace Prize
1995: Released from house arrest, but movements restricted
2000-02: Second period of house arrest
May 2003: Detained after clash between NLD and junta forces
Sep 2003: Allowed home after medical treatment, but under effective house arrest
May 2007: House arrest is extended for another year
Sept 2007: First public appearance since 2003, greeting protesting Buddhist monks
May 2008: House arrest extended for another year
May 2009: Charged with breaking detention rules after an American swims to her compound
August 2009: Sentenced to 18 months further house arrest
She was again put under house arrest in September 2000, when she tried to travel to the city of Mandalay in defiance of travel restrictions.
She was released unconditionally in May 2002, but just over a year later she was put in prison following a clash between her supporters and a government-backed mob.
Following a gynaecological operation in September 2003, she was allowed to return home - but again under effective house arrest.
In summer 2007, there were widespread protests in Burma over fuel prices, followed by anti-government demonstrations led by Buddhist monks, which were violently ended by the government.
Ms Suu Kyi appeared outside her home to meet some of the monks in September that year, her first public appearance since 2003.
In May 2009, as the latest period of detention was due to expire, the NLD appealed to the government to release her, saying she was suffering from low blood pressure and dehydration, but the appeal was rejected.
Shortly after, a US national was arrested for swimming across a lake and breaking into her compound.

Then, a few days later, Ms Suu Kyi was herself arrested and charged with breaching the conditions of her detention, although the man had apparently not been invited to visit.
After a trial, she was convicted and sentenced to a further 18 months of house arrest.
Critics say the arrest and continued detention were designed to keep her away from the public eye until elections scheduled to take place in 2010.
The sentence was roundly condemned by the international community.
Diplomatic visits
During periods of confinement, Ms Suu Kyi has busied herself studying and exercising.
I could not, as my father's daughter, remain indifferent to all that was going on
Aung San Suu Kyi, 1988
She has meditated, worked on her French and Japanese language skills, and relaxed by playing Bach on the piano.
In more recent years, she has also been able to meet other NLD officials, and selected visiting diplomats like the United Nations special envoy Razali Ismail.
But during her early years of detention, Ms Suu Kyi was often in solitary confinement - and was not even allowed to see her two sons or her husband, British academic Michael Aris, who died of cancer in March 1999.
When her husband was on his deathbed, the military authorities offered to allow her to travel to the UK to see him, but she felt compelled to refuse for fear she would not be allowed back into the country.
Ms Suu Kyi has often said that detention has made her even more resolute to dedicate the rest of her life to represent the average Burmese citizen.
The UN special envoy Razali Ismail has said privately that she is one of the most impressive people he has ever met.
Overseas life
Much of Ms Suu Kyi's appeal within Burma lies in the fact she is the daughter of the country's independence hero, General Aung San.
Aung San Suu Kyi after her release from detention in 1995

He was assassinated during the transition period in July 1947, just six months before independence.
Aung San Suu Kyi was only two years old at the time.
In 1960 she went to India with her mother Daw Khin Kyi, who had been appointed Burma's ambassador to Delhi.
Four years later she went to Oxford University in the UK, where she studied philosophy, politics and economics. There she met her future husband.
After stints of living and working in Japan and Bhutan, she settled down to be an English don's housewife and raise their two children, Alexander and Kim.
But Burma was never far away from her thoughts.
When she arrived back in Rangoon in 1988 - initially to look after her critically ill mother - Burma was in the midst of major political upheaval.
Thousands of students, office workers and monks took to the streets demanding democratic reform.
"I could not, as my father's daughter remain indifferent to all that was going on," she said in a speech in Rangoon on 26 August 1988.
Ms Suu Kyi was soon propelled into leading the revolt against then-dictator General Ne Win.
Inspired by the non-violent campaigns of US civil rights leader Martin Luther King and India's Mahatma Gandhi, she organised rallies and travelled around the country, calling for peaceful democratic reform and free elections.
But the demonstrations were brutally suppressed by the army, who seized power in a coup on 18 September 1988.
The military government called national elections in May 1990.
Aung San Suu Kyi's NLD convincingly won the polls, despite the fact that she herself was under house arrest and disqualified from standing.
But the junta refused to hand over control, and has remained in power ever since.

Is Burma softening its stance?

Page last updated at 02:09 GMT, Thursday, 29 October 2009

Is Burma softening its stance?

By Alastair Leithead
BBC Asia correspondent

Supporters of Aung San Suu Kyi in Seoul, South Korea
Despite worldwide indignation, Ms Suu Kyi is still under house arrest
This month Burma's pro-democracy leader Aung San Suu Kyi passed two milestones.
The first was 14 years - that is the amount of time she has now spent in detention during the past two decades.
The second was to meet Western diplomats and begin talks with Burmese military leaders - talks which some think could see her released.
"Given the impasse of the last 20 years, what has happened in the last three months gives us the hope there will be some movement," says Derek Tonkin, a former British ambassador and current Burma activist.
There seemed little hope of progress in August, when Burmese pro-democracy leader Aung San Suu Kyi, known as The Lady, had her house arrest extended by 18 months for allowing an uninvited American man to stay in her lakeside home after swimming to see her.
While the controversial court case was going on, the Obama adminstration was looking at engagement within a review of its Burma strategy ahead of elections planned for Burma next year.
This was happening amid the fear of increasing Chinese influence in the gap left by Western isolation.
'Pragmatic engagement'
Soon after the trial ended, Senator Jim Webb became the most senior US official to meet Burma's top general, Than Shwe.
He was also allowed to see Aung San Suu Kyi - something even UN Secretary General Ban Ki-Moon could not do.
Senator Jim Webb
Senator Jim Webb was allowed to visit Aung San Suu Kyi
As a man reporting back directly to President Barack Obama, his message that "sanctions hadn't worked" was what the generals wanted to hear.
He emphasised the increased influence of China as well - an Asia-wide trend that has Washington worried.
The next step was a switch in US policy towards "pragmatic engagement" - in other words, direct senior level dialogue with the leadership.
US demands include the release of political prisoners, including Ms Suu Kyi, but what are they offering in return?
The only high-value card is sanctions, and that is what The Lady also used to open her own talks.
Her recent letter to number one general Than Shwe requested a meeting with Western diplomats for her to establish what sanctions are in place, and it was permitted within a week.
"The generals are looking for international recognition for the 2010 election. They are trying to co-opt Aung San Suu Kyi and her National League for Democracy to take part in the elections without any constitutional change," said Derek Tonkin.
"We are still waiting for a really significant movement, but I could see Aung San Suu Kyi being released before the election if they could secure an understanding."
An end to sanctions?
The message from Burma's Prime Minister Thein Sein at the recent meeting of the Association of South East Asian Nations (Asean) in Thailand was that the ruling generals see a role for Ms Suu Kyi in fostering reconciliation, according to Thai Prime Minister Abhisit Vejjajiva - and that the conditions of her detention could be relaxed.
Monk in Rangoon

Thant Myint-U, a Burmese historian and author whose grandfather was UN Secretary General U Thant, thinks her early release is possible but unlikely. He believes the purpose of the talks is partly to find out what exactly the Burmese want.
"It is extremely unlikely the US Congress will overturn sanctions, but if the US government thinks the Burma generals are moving in the right direction there are other things they can do," he said.
"Everything from using the name Myanmar, rather than Burma, to lifting some of the restrictions the US has on multilateral co-operation to assistance programmes."
US Assistant Secretary of State Kurt Campbell made it clear that dialogue would supplement rather than replace sanctions.
"We will maintain our existing sanctions until we see concrete progress," he told the US House Committee on Foreign Affairs this month.
"We believe any easing of sanctions now would send the wrong signal to those who have been striving for so many years for democracy in Burma."
Europe's stance
Mark Farmaner, from Burma Campaign UK, which has strongly supported sanctions, said the US policy of demanding results is what the UN has failed to do, and will put extreme pressure on the regime.
"Sanctions were always meant to be one of the few tools to give them leverage to force the generals into talks, but they should not be given away unless you get something in return," he said.
"One hundred political prisoners of more than 2,000 are seriously ill and being systematically refused medical treatment. The regime is ruthlessly pushing ahead with its agenda. You have to look at history and come back down to earth.
File image of Burma's top general, Than Shwe
The junta have sometimes seemed impervious to international criticism
"We are afraid of EU countries pre-emptively lifting sanctions and that would send the wrong message to the generals," he added.
There doesn't appear to be much fear of that, as the European Union still has not made an official statement.
Some sources suggest this is because Britain is "dragging its heels" and urging collective caution.
But Western diplomats say Europe will soon open up its own dialogue with Burma, following the US lead.
"The elections may not be free and fair, but we need to be there anyway," diplomats say, pointing out it's the first opportunity in 20 years for any change at all, and the West has to position itself to engage with a new government made up of at least some elected civilians.
So does that mean lifting some European sanctions? Only in co-ordination with the US policy, but it's understood consideration is being put to the mechanics of what might be lifted and when.
This could include the re-opening to Burma of special EU trade access for developing countries, or allowing access to international financial institutions like the World Bank, the International Monetary Fund and the Asian Development Bank.
Author Thant Myint-U thinks the ruling generals will balance their image abroad and better relations with the West against their well-established plans for a "democratic" Burma.
"There is concern among some quarters in Burma of an over-reliance on China, and as the US is the only balancer they think it is time to reach out to the US," he said.
Progress is slow, but as one diplomat said "anything can happen in Burma".